A 1-star review? What do I do?

Lopez Island, WA, United States

Acknowledge, Empathize, and Apologize

We all have been there.

And know that sinking feeling when your inbox banners in a 1-star review notification. Gosh darn it, and their story isn’t even accurate; they left out so many details leading up to this issue, painting your company as a bad guy. We pour ourselves into our businesses, and that attack feels personal, and their story is blown way out of proportion. And all of our 5-star reviews and happy customers are forgotten about. 

Did you know that 17% of Yelp reviews are 1-star ratings? 1-star reviews are more common than you may think; however, they never feel good, nor do they bode well for your ratings, because they count against your Google rankings, potentially driving away prospective customers and occasionally giving pause to current customers who may begin to seek out another shop for auto repair services. Preserving your reputation is one good reason to respond to 1-star reviews. A well-thought-out written response can bring in business and build customer loyalty and ideally also salvage your relationship with that unhappy customer.

The message you send through your reply can be a powerful tool. Not only can you have the potential to convert your disgruntled customer into a raving fan, but you also have the opportunity to set your company’s tone and show the world how you manage a difficult situation. Did you know that 96% of people who read reviews also read the responses? This means that every response is an opportunity to convert a shopper into a customer. This is a response opportunity to convert a shopper into a customer.

What, if anything, should we do next? Here is how we suggest handling 1-star review posts.


Contact them directly

We suggest first trying to contact your client by phone to see if you can make things right with them, and naturally, it would follow for them to remove their 1-star review. Things go wrong in every business, and often, by addressing the issue directly and showing sincerity in your attempt to acknowledge and correct the mishap, you come out with a stronger relationship and often end up with a raving fan on your side.


How do I respond to their review?

Take the time to think about the interaction from their perspective and make it about them. This is their experience and is their way of venting and possibly even inviting you to reach out with an olive branch. How do we make peace with a hurting individual? By acknowledging and validating them, making them feel heard, addressing their concern, and inviting them to interact to make things right. It is important to thank them for taking the time to share their experience so you have an opportunity to engage further and develop a deeper relationship. Going through something together and coming out the other side often builds a deeper connection and increased loyalty.


Thank them for reviewing your company

Find a way to express gratitude and thank them for taking the time to provide you with a learning opportunity. Even though you are not thrilled to have a 1-star review, it is important to validate the reviewer and acknowledge them for taking the time to provide feedback. This simple step alone shows professionalism and courtesy, which bodes well with relationship building from all directions.


Acknowledge, Empathize, and Apologize 

This can be a tricky thing to navigate. However, it is important to master. You do not want to look unprofessional by apologizing profusely, and you also want to avoid coming across as disingenuous. You want your customer to feel validated and heard, and you want them to feel that you are taking responsibility for what went sideways. 

So, what is the best way to write an apology? Keep it concise. A response like “We apologize on behalf of everyone at our shop. We always aim to deliver a great experience. We’re normally known for our exceptional attention to detail, your situation was an exception, and we regret that we missed the mark. You have our commitment to improving the way our staff serves every customer, and we will use your experience as a training opportunity with our team to ensure that this won’t happen again. Please give us a call at your earliest convenience. We ask that you accept our sincerest apologies on behalf of everyone on the team.” this shows that in your apology, you are committed to taking action, validating the customer, and we will use this as a training opportunity. This also helps shift the focus from a mistake to your dedication to improving the customer experience, reframing the 1-star review into an opportunity to focus on showing your dedication to providing superior customer service.


Take the conversation offline

In the above review response, we have asked the customer to contact us at their earliest convenience; this provides the customer the opportunity to vent offline, you the opportunity to correct the mistake, come up with a resolution, and provide the customer reassurance that you are sincere. 

We want to encourage you to respond to a 1-star review even if you have resolved the issue offline; this allows other consumers to see how you handle difficult situations. Protecting your reputation is vital, and no matter if the comments and reviews are positive or negative, they get seen by hundreds, maybe even thousands of people. If you are feeling stuck and want help crafting a response, the team at Bird’s iSocial is here to help you; feel free to reach out!

By Melissa Patterson September 10, 2025
Neuroinclusivity in the Bays
By Melissa Patterson August 16, 2025
Let’s be honest. If you're an independent shop owner, you probably wear more hats than a mannequin in a western wear store. One minute, you're managing payroll. The next, you're explaining to a customer why a 6-month-old tire is bald (spoiler alert: it’s not your fault). By 4 p.m., you’re elbow-deep in QuickBooks, trying to remember what “reconciliation” even means. You’re not lazy. You’re not unmotivated. You’re just maxed out. And the truth is, if you don’t learn to delegate, burnout isn’t just a possibility. It’s a guarantee. "But no one can do it like I do..." I’ve heard it. I’ve said it. It’s the classic line of a burnt-out owner-operator stuck in the daily grind. And I get it. You’ve built your business with your own two hands. You’ve got a standard. A pace. A feel. And letting go of control feels like a risk. But here’s the kicker: holding on to everything is the bigger risk. Because when everything depends on you, everything can fall apart because of you. What happens if you get sick? Or you need a break? Or, heaven forbid, you want to take a Friday off without your phone buzzing every 15 minutes? This isn’t just about freedom. It’s about building a business that can breathe without you. One that works with you - not only because of you. Signs You're Headed for Burnout Let’s do a little self-check. If any of these sound familiar, it might be time to hit pause and take a closer look at how you’re leading: You're constantly putting out fires instead of planning ahead You skip lunch more often than not You don’t trust your team to handle anything without you You wake up already exhausted Your to-do list never ends- it just rearranges itself You secretly fantasize about selling everything and opening a taco stand in Cabo (no judgment) Burnout doesn’t always show up as a meltdown. Sometimes, it creeps in like a slow leak. Quiet. Dangerous. And if you're not paying attention, it'll flatten you. Delegation Isn’t Dumping - It’s Developing Here’s what most people get wrong: Delegation doesn’t mean handing off the junk you don’t want to deal with. It means training someone to succeed. You’re not just giving tasks - you’re growing people. One of Maylan’s favorite truths was this: “You didn’t buy a business. You bought a job - if you have to be there all the time.” And he was right. The real test of your shop isn’t what happens when you’re there. It’s what happens when you’re not. When you delegate well, you do three big things: You free up your time for leadership. Strategy. Vision. Growth. That’s your job - not counting oil filters. You build team confidence. People want to know you trust them. Give them a lane, and they’ll learn to drive it. You protect your peace. There’s no badge of honor in burnout. You can't lead on empty. What Should You Delegate? Glad you asked. Here’s a quick list of what you can start letting go of - without letting go of quality: ✅ Daily Operational Tasks Parts ordering Scheduling Inventory checks Drop-off/pick-up coordination ✅ Customer Communication Follow-up calls and reminders Review responses Social media comments and DMs ✅ Marketing Posting to social Replying to messages Updating your Google Business Profile Blog writing (hi, that’s us!) ✅ Admin Payroll prep Receipt filing Email sorting Look, you don’t have to give it all away at once. Start with one thing. See how it goes. Then try another. “But What If They Mess It Up?” They might. That’s part of the process. Delegation requires patience, coaching, and expecting a few bumps along the way. You’re not just offloading work - you’re investing in your people. When someone drops the ball, you don’t snatch it back and say, “Forget it - I’ll do it myself.” You teach. You adjust. You lead. That’s how real businesses grow. Not through perfection, but through progress. Delegate with Purpose: 5 Quick Tips Let’s make this practical. If you’re ready to dip your toe in the delegation pool, start here: 1. Pick the Right Person Give the task to someone whose natural strengths match the work. Don’t give data entry to your tech who can't sit still. 2. Be Crystal Clear Vague instructions = disappointing results. Take 10 minutes to clearly explain the goal and the steps. Bonus points if you write it down or record a short video. 3. Set a Follow-Up Time Don’t just toss the baton and run. Schedule a check-in. It keeps you both accountable. 4. Encourage Ownership Let them know you’re trusting them - and you’re not hovering. Give room to figure things out. 5. Praise Progress, Not Perfection If they got 80% right and missed a few details? That’s still a win. Celebrate effort, guide improvement. The Long Game: From Owner to Leader Imagine this... It’s 4:30 on a Thursday. You’re not stressed. Payroll is handled. Marketing is humming. Phones are ringing - and someone else is answering them. You’re sipping coffee, reviewing next month’s goals, maybe even planning a real weekend away. That’s not a fantasy. That’s what delegation makes possible. You didn’t start your shop to become its prisoner. You started it to build something lasting. Something that could support your family, serve your community, and give you freedom. But freedom doesn’t show up when everything’s perfect. It shows up when you let go of what’s holding you back. So today, ask yourself: What am I doing that someone else could do - with training Then make a move. Because if you don’t delegate, you will burn out. And your shop - your team - needs more than your hands. They need your mind. Your vision. Your leadership. You can build a business that runs without burning you out. And if you’re ready to get the ball rolling but not sure where to start? Shoot us a message, and we’ll help you find your first delegation win!:)
By Melissa Patterson August 15, 2025
Let’s start with a quick gut-check: When was the last time you Googled your own shop? Not to see if the internet still knows you exist, but to actually look at your listing, your photos, your reviews, your hours. At how a brand-new customer might see you for the very first time. For a lot of shop owners, the answer is... “uh, maybe never?” That’s a missed opportunity. Because when someone types “auto repair near me,” your Google Business Profile (GBP) is front and center. It’s the front porch to your shop online - and if it’s a mess, outdated, or missing altogether, you’re not just invisible. You’re losing cars before they ever pull in the lot. So, let’s fix that. Here’s a practical, no-fluff checklist of local SEO tips to help your Google listing actually work for you - and bring in the right customers without spending a dime on ads. 1. Claim It. Own It. Keep It Updated. First things first; make sure you’ve claimed your Google Business Profile. If you haven’t done that yet, stop reading and go do it right now. Seriously. We’ll wait. Once you’ve claimed it, don’t just “set it and forget it.” Your profile needs regular check-ins. ✅ Are your hours current? ✅ Is your phone number correct? ✅ Do you have holiday hours scheduled? ✅ Have you added a short, clear description that explains what kind of shop you are and who you serve? If your listing still says “Call for hours” or has a blurry photo from 2023... we can do better. 2. Use Keywords, But Keep It Human Google scans your profile for keywords to help decide when to show your shop in search results. That means your business description, services, and even photo captions can all give you a little ranking boost—if you write them with intention. 🚫 Don't keyword-stuff like a robot. ✅ Do include phrases like: “Auto repair in [your city]” “Brake repair specialists” “Family-owned diesel mechanic” Write like a real person talking to a customer. Because that’s who it’s for. 3. Photos That Actually Show Who You Are Here’s where most shop listings fall flat: the visuals. They either don’t have any photos, or they upload 37 shots of valve covers and timing belts. (I get it. You’re proud of your work. But customers aren’t trying to hire a parts catalog.) What they do want to see: The front of your building (so they recognize it when they drive by) Your team in action (bonus points for smiles!) Your waiting area A couple clean, finished cars Any family-friendly or unique touches (mascot dog? community board? donut day?) Aim for at least 10 solid photos. Update them every few months so your listing feels alive - not forgotten. 4. Get Those Reviews Flowing (and Respond to Them All) Reviews aren’t a “nice to have.” They’re trust currency. Most people aren’t clicking on a shop with two stars and no responses. And they’re not going to trust a place with perfect 5.0 stars and only three reviews from the owner's family members either. You want steady, recent, real reviews; and yes, you can ask for them. 📢 Pro tip: Train your team to spot the “thank you” moments in customer conversations. That’s when you say: “We really appreciate that. If you have a minute, would you be willing to share that in a Google review? It helps more than you know.” And once that review goes live? Always respond, even if it’s just “Thanks so much for the kind words, we loved working on your Jeep!” Got a negative review? Don’t panic. Breathe. Reply calmly, own what’s real, and show you care about making it right. That response says more to future customers than the bad review ever could. 5. Use Posts to Stay Fresh Did you know you can post updates directly to your Google listing? Most shops don’t use this feature, but it’s free, visible, and helps show Google that you’re active. You can post: Seasonal specials Holiday hours Customer shoutouts Blog links (like this one!) Reminders like “Book early before school starts” Keep it short, visual, and relevant - just once a week is a great rhythm. 6. Answer the Questions Before They’re Asked There’s a “Q&A” section on your profile where people can ask questions... and anyone can answer them. Here’s the hack: Ask your own FAQs and answer them yourself. Example: Q: Do you work on diesels? A: Yes! We specialize in diesel repair, including Ford Powerstroke, Duramax, and Cummins systems. Now, when someone types “diesel mechanic near me,” guess who just got a visibility bump? You. Wrapping It Up Google isn’t magic. It’s math, strategy, and consistency. And your shop doesn’t need to outspend anyone - you just need to show up smarter. 📍 Claim your profile 📷 Keep it updated with real photos ⭐ Build review momentum 🛠️ Post weekly, answer questions, and use keywords like a human You’ve already built a business people can trust. Let’s make sure your Google listing reflects that. Need help writing your listing? Want me to audit it with fresh eyes? That’s what we do. 👋 Drop us a message and let’s make sure your shop is getting found first- organically, authentically, and in a way that actually works. #BirdsiSocial #LocalSEO #GoogleBusinessTips #AutoRepairMarketing #ShopLeadership #FixCarsGrowBusiness #BirdieSays
By Melissa Patterson June 1, 2024
Adapting Your Marketing Strategy for Every Generation
By Melissa Patterson May 1, 2024
Why it is Important to Ask Customers to Rate Your Auto Repair Shop Online 
By Melissa Patterson March 18, 2024
Nurturing Loyalty, Trust, and Satisfaction in the Automotive Service Industry
By Melissa Patterson January 31, 2024
What is Apple Business Connect?
By Melissa Patterson August 31, 2023
In today's digital landscape, community engagement has become a cornerstone of successful marketing strategies for businesses, including independent auto repair shops.
By Melissa Patterson July 31, 2023
In our digital age, online reviews have become the lifeblood of businesses, especially for automotive repair shops.
By Melissa Patterson July 1, 2023
Your success as a content creator for your shop is in your hands, and we're here to navigate the road with you!